You Are Performing Even When No One Is Watching
A stream on the Camino had no opinion of me, and in its company the self-monitoring finally went quiet.

There is a voice that grades your quiet moments.
You know the one. It rereads the email after you send it, hunting for the wrong word. It sits in the meeting, scoring your last comment while everyone else has moved on. If you are a student, it hovers over the finished essay, asking whether it was ever good enough to hand in. It follows you home, checks how the meditation is going while you meditate, watches you rest, and asks whether you are resting well. Long after the day’s audience has gone home, it stays on duty, narrating and scoring, and because it lives in your own head, there is nowhere it cannot follow you.
I want to name what that voice actually is, because for years I mistook it for awareness. It is a supervisor. Its work is control, keeping you performing to standard even when no one is there to perform for. A life supervised without relief, including in the hours you call rest, is a life short of freedom, however alone you manage to be.
I learned this from a stream in France, but first, I had to catch the supervisor traveling with me.
The Watcher I Carried onto the Camino
I walk the Camino alone each summer as a personal retreat, in silence, and you might think that settles it.
No conversation, no obligations, no one for hundreds of miles who knows my name. By the common measure of freedom, a person walking alone through rural France has as much of it as anyone alive. Yet in the first days of a walk, I can catch the old voice still at work. How is the retreat going? Am I present enough yet? Was that hour contemplative or merely tired? The supervisor had packed itself in my bag, and it was grading my solitude the way it grades everything else.
That is the honest and slightly embarrassing truth about self-monitoring. It needs no audience. It is the audience, portable and permanent, and even a pilgrimage can become one more performance reviewed from the inside.
Alone, in silence, on an ancient path, I remained short of fully free, because I was never actually alone. The watcher was there.
The Stream That Had No Opinion of Me
Partway through the final morning, the path crossed a stream, and I stopped beside it.
I had nowhere to be by any hour, so I stayed, longer than a rest needed. The water came down over the stones and went on under the trees, doing what it had been doing before I arrived and would keep doing after I left. It carried on entirely without reference to me. Nearly everything else in a day responds to us, people answer, screens measure, even the dog reads your mood, and the supervisor lives on all of it, combing every response for a verdict on how you are doing.
While I sat there, a cow came down the far bank and drank. The stream gave her what she came for and kept moving, the same sound over the same stones, unchanged by being needed. Even met directly by another life, it carried on, offering without tallying what it gave. I have never once managed to give that way, without some part of me recording the gift.
The stream withheld all of it. It offered no reaction to interpret, no progress to assess, no mirror at all. My attention went out to the water, and I found nothing there about me.
The voice went quiet. It had been given nothing to grade, and the supervisor, unemployed, sat down. What flooded into the vacancy was a kind of liberty I had almost forgotten, attention with no manager attached, the first unsupervised minutes I could remember in a long while.
What the Lightness Was Telling Me
The relief by the water was pleasant. What it revealed mattered more.
That lightness was diagnostic. It was the feel of being uncontrolled, and the strangeness of the feeling told me how constant the control had been. You do not notice a weight you have carried for years until something lifts it, and then the lightness itself becomes the measure of the load. Sitting by water that asked nothing of me, I could finally feel how much of my ordinary attention goes to management, the constant quiet work of watching myself on behalf of standards no one present was holding me to.
This, I think, is also why the silence of walking matters so much to me, and why, on this same Camino, a cow in a field could meet my eyes and reach me. The supervisor has to go off duty before anything living can get through. Freedom from the watcher is more than rest. It is the condition for being met.
Company That Asks Nothing of You
You do not need a stream in France, though I recommend one if it ever offers itself.
You need something nearby that carries on without reference to you. Moving water is the classic company, a creek, a fountain, rain working down a gutter, though wind in a single tree will do it just as well. Sit near it without a task. Let your attention go out to it and stay there a while. Then notice, without turning it into one more evaluation, what the voice does when there is nothing for it to score.
You may find, as I did, that the quiet arriving in that moment is your own company as it feels when no one is supervising it, including you.
The stream was still running when I shouldered my pack. It had never once looked up.
Where do you go when you need to be somewhere that asks nothing of you, and what happens to the grading voice when you get there? I would be glad to hear about it in the comments.
If you find this useful, please like or leave a comment.
The Rewilding the Soul EcoSpirituality Certificate at Cherry Hill Seminary, where I teach, is currently underway with this year’s cohort. The September 2026 Contemplative Walking Retreat I am leading on this same section of the Le Puy Camino is full. New offerings, including future retreats and additional teaching opportunities, will be announced here in the months ahead. For now, the practice itself is what matters most, and it is available to you wherever you are walking this week.
Where Insight Meets Earth is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.


Jeffrey, I so appreciate the language you use re: supervision. As we know, as a reader I interpret and take away what speaks to me…my ‘ear’ only hears what it wants to hear! So, as I planned to focus on spiritual direction supervision and my upcoming classes and curriculum today, instead I pause to absorb your words. This pause will serve me well. May it also serve my students well as it nourishes the teachings I hope to offer. May it be so.
Thank you, dear friend and colleague!