Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sheri Handel's avatar

Your concern about the welfare of this tree and approach to making the decision you had to make resonated. I live on Manhattan's Upper West Side, with Riverside Park about a block away from me and Central Park a little over a mile away. I don't have any decision-making powers over what happens to our local trees and gardens, but my many of neighbors and myself are quite tuned into what happens with them. This summer and fall two local trees were taken--a Basswood by a storm, and a huge Elm by the parks department because it had experienced stuctural damage. So sad.

Leigh Fletcher's avatar

I have an oak tree that is leaning on the little (former single car garage) wooden house in my backyard. Three years ago, I opted to alter the roofline of the house to give the tree more room. Then I added a post to support the part of the tree that wanted to lean on the new lower roof. But the tree is back on the roof. I don't feel removing it is the right thing to do but I may have some upper dead branches pruned to lighten it, or I may tear down half the building, or maybe I will just wait and see.

2 more comments...

Ready for more?